Description
Compare Your Product with a Competitor or Previous Batch
Why do two products appear similar but perform differently?
Why does a new batch behave differently from an older batch?
Do you want to understand what measurable chemical, elemental, physical or thermal differences exist between your product and a competitor’s product?
Labsure provides comparative chemical analysis for Australian manufacturers and product developers.
We compare two or more product samples using analytical techniques selected according to the materials and the questions you need to answer.
Comparative analysis may be used for:
- Your product vs competitor product
- New batch vs previous batch
- New formulation vs original formulation
- Your raw material vs alternative supplier material
- Normal product vs abnormal product
- Approved reference sample vs new production sample
Depending on the product, our analytical approach may include:
FTIR · GC-MS · HPLC · XRF · XRD · TGA · PSD
From $995 AUD + GST
Typical turnaround: 20–30 business days
You don’t need to know which tests you need.
Tell us what products you want to compare and what difference you are trying to understand. Labsure can review the samples and recommend an appropriate analytical program.
What Can Comparative Product Analysis Help You Find Out?
Comparative analysis can help investigate whether two products have measurable differences in their chemical, elemental, physical or thermal characteristics.
Why Do Two Products Perform Differently?
If two products have similar intended uses but produce different results, analytical comparison may help identify measurable differences between the samples.
These differences may relate to:
- Chemical composition
- Organic components
- Inorganic materials
- Mineral phases
- Elemental composition
- Polymer or resin characteristics
- Particle size distribution
- Thermal behaviour
- Volatile or semi-volatile components
Analytical results can provide technical information for further formulation, manufacturing or quality investigations.
Is My Product Different From a Competitor’s Product?
If you have your own product and a competitor’s product, Labsure can compare selected chemical and material characteristics.
Depending on the samples, testing may include:
FTIR + GC-MS/HPLC + XRF/XRD + TGA + PSD
The exact combination depends on the composition and analytical objectives.
The purpose is to identify measurable differences between the samples, rather than simply generating a set of laboratory results.
Has My New Batch Changed?
If a new production batch is performing differently from a previous batch, comparative analysis can help investigate whether there are measurable differences.
For example:
- Previous batch vs new batch
- Approved batch vs failed batch
- Normal product vs abnormal product
- Before production change vs after production change
This can support manufacturing and quality-control investigations.
Are Two Products Chemically Similar?
Analytical comparison can help determine whether two samples show similar or different analytical profiles.
Depending on the material, we may compare:
- FTIR spectra
- Chromatographic profiles
- Elemental composition
- Mineral phases
- Thermal behaviour
- Particle size distribution
The level of comparison depends on the analytical methods selected and the characteristics of the samples.
Analytical Techniques
FTIR
Chemical Fingerprinting and Material Identification
Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) can provide a characteristic chemical fingerprint for many organic, polymeric and formulated materials.
FTIR may be useful for comparing:
- Cleaning products
- Coatings
- Adhesives
- Resins
- Polymers
- Surfactant-containing products
- Other organic chemical products
Comparing FTIR spectra can help identify similarities and differences in the major infrared-active components of two samples.
GC-MS
Volatile and Semi-Volatile Organic Components
Gas Chromatography–Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS) can be considered for suitable volatile and semi-volatile organic compounds.
It may help compare:
- Solvents
- Fragrance components
- Organic additives
- Volatile ingredients
- Semi-volatile components
- Other suitable organic compounds
GC-MS can be particularly useful when differences in the organic chemical profile may contribute to differences between two products.
HPLC
Non-Volatile Organic Components
High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) can be considered for suitable non-volatile organic compounds and active components.
It may help compare:
- Organic additives
- Active components
- Specialty chemicals
- Non-volatile compounds
- Suitable formulation components
HPLC can provide chromatographic comparison between suitable samples.
XRF
Elemental Composition
X-ray Fluorescence (XRF) can provide elemental composition information for suitable solid or inorganic materials.
It may be useful when comparing:
- Fillers
- Pigments
- Mineral components
- Inorganic powders
- Ceramic-related materials
- Metal-containing materials
XRF can help determine whether two samples have similar or different elemental profiles.
XRD
Mineral and Crystalline Phase Comparison
X-ray Diffraction (XRD) can be considered for crystalline powders, minerals, fillers, pigments and other suitable solid materials.
XRD may help compare:
- Mineral phases
- Crystalline compounds
- Inorganic fillers
- Pigments
- Powdered materials
Two products may contain similar elements but have different crystalline phases. XRD can help investigate these differences.
TGA
Thermal Behaviour and Composition
Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) measures changes in sample mass as temperature changes under controlled conditions.
TGA may help compare:
- Thermal stability
- Moisture or volatile loss
- Decomposition behaviour
- Organic/inorganic content
- Polymer or resin characteristics
- Thermal differences between batches
PSD
Particle Size Distribution
For powdered or particulate products, Particle Size Distribution (PSD) can be important.
Two products may have similar chemical identities but different particle size distributions, which may affect:
- Processing
- Dispersion
- Application
- Surface finish
- Stability
- Product performance
PSD can therefore provide useful information when comparing powders, fillers, pigments, mineral materials and other particulate products.
Typical Products We Compare
Comparative Product Analysis can be applied to a wide range of chemical and formulated products, including:
Cleaning Products
- Industrial cleaners
- Degreasers
- Detergents
- Surface cleaners
- Specialty cleaning products
Coatings
- Protective coatings
- Industrial coatings
- Automotive coatings
- Surface treatments
- Ceramic-related coatings
Adhesives
- Industrial adhesives
- Construction adhesives
- Pressure-sensitive adhesives
- Resin-based adhesive systems
Microcement and Construction Materials
- Microcement products
- Resins
- Cementitious materials
- Fillers
- Mineral powders
- Construction additives
Other Chemical Products
- Chemical formulations
- Industrial additives
- Specialty chemicals
- Polymers and resins
- Powders and fillers
- Pigments
- Other manufacturing materials
Comparative Analysis Examples
Example 1 — Your Product vs Competitor Product
You have developed a cleaning product but believe a competitor’s product performs better.
You provide:
Sample A – Your Product
Sample B – Competitor Product
Depending on the product, Labsure may recommend a combination such as:
FTIR + GC-MS/HPLC + TGA
The results can help investigate measurable differences in the chemical and thermal characteristics of the two products.
Example 2 — New Batch vs Previous Batch
Your previous batch performed well, but the latest production batch produces a different result.
You provide:
Sample A – Previous Batch
Sample B – New Batch
Depending on the material, the analysis may include:
FTIR + XRF/XRD + TGA + PSD
This can help determine whether measurable chemical, elemental, mineral, thermal or particle-size differences exist between the batches.
Example 3 — Alternative Supplier Comparison
You are considering changing suppliers for an important raw material.
You provide:
Sample A – Existing Supplier
Sample B – New Supplier
Comparative testing can help investigate whether the two materials have similar analytical characteristics before you introduce the alternative material into production.
What Does the Final Report Include?
Depending on the analytical program, your report may include:
Sample Identification
Sample descriptions, sample references and analytical scope.
Comparative Analytical Results
Relevant results such as:
- FTIR spectra
- GC-MS chromatograms
- HPLC chromatograms
- XRF elemental results
- XRD results
- TGA data
- PSD results
Comparative Interpretation
Where supported by the analytical data, the report can explain:
- Major similarities
- Major differences
- Measurable differences between samples
- Relevant analytical findings
- Potential areas for further investigation
The objective is to provide useful technical information for product development, manufacturing and quality investigations, rather than simply supplying raw laboratory data.
One Comparison Does Not Always Need Every Test
We do not automatically perform every analytical technique on every pair of samples.
The appropriate analytical program depends on:
- Product type
- Sample composition
- Physical form
- Your comparison objective
- Available reference samples
- Expected composition
- Sample quantity
- Required analytical sensitivity
For example:
Organic Formulated Product
FTIR + GC-MS / HPLC
may be considered depending on the chemical characteristics.
Mineral or Inorganic Product
XRF + XRD + PSD
may be appropriate for investigating elemental, mineral and particle-size differences.
Polymer or Resin Product
FTIR + TGA
may provide useful comparative information.
Complex Formulated Product
A combination of FTIR, GC-MS, HPLC, XRF, XRD, TGA and PSD may be considered depending on the analytical objective.
You don’t need to select the instruments yourself.
Tell us what products you want to compare and what you are trying to understand. We can recommend an appropriate analytical approach.
Who Is This Service For?
Our Comparative Product Analysis service is suitable for Australian businesses involved in:
- Chemical manufacturing
- Cleaning product manufacturing
- Coatings
- Adhesives
- Construction materials
- Microcement
- Specialty chemicals
- Industrial formulations
- Product development
- Quality control
It can be particularly useful for manufacturers and product developers who need to investigate:
- Competitor products
- Product performance differences
- Batch variation
- Formulation changes
- Alternative suppliers
- Manufacturing problems
- Quality issues
How Our Comparative Product Analysis Works
1. Tell Us About the Products
Provide information about the products you want to compare, including their intended use and any available product information.
2. Explain What You Want to Understand
Tell us why you are comparing the products and what difference you are trying to investigate.
3. Provide Your Samples
Ideally, provide the products you want compared. A reference sample can be particularly useful for batch or supplier comparisons.
4. We Recommend the Analytical Program
We select analytical techniques according to the materials and your analytical objective.
5. Receive a Quotation
We confirm the analytical scope, price and estimated turnaround before testing begins.
6. Analysis and Comparative Report
The samples are analysed using the agreed analytical program, followed by technical review and comparative reporting.
Why Choose Labsure?
Problem-Focused Analysis
We start with the question you need answered, rather than automatically selecting a standard testing package.
Multiple Analytical Techniques
Our analytical capability includes FTIR, NMR, HPLC, GC-MS, LC-MS/MS, XRD, XRF, SEM/EDS, PSD, TGA, IC and ICP-OES, allowing different techniques to be considered for different products.
Suitable for Australian SMEs
You don’t need to maintain your own analytical laboratory or determine the analytical method yourself.
Fixed Quotation Before Testing
We review your requirements and confirm the analytical scope and price before proceeding.
Independent Comparative Investigation
Useful for competitor comparison, batch investigation, supplier comparison, formulation development and manufacturing troubleshooting.
Pricing
Comparative Product Analysis — From $995 AUD + GST
Typical Pricing: $995–$1,995 AUD + GST
The final price depends on:
- Number of samples
- Product complexity
- Analytical techniques required
- Sample preparation requirements
- Analytical sensitivity
- Number of comparative tests
- Complexity of technical interpretation
Typical Turnaround: 20–30 Business Days
Complex comparative investigations or projects requiring multiple analytical techniques may require a longer turnaround.
Important Information
Comparative analytical testing can identify measurable differences in the chemical, elemental, physical or thermal characteristics of samples.
However, analytical comparison does not necessarily establish the complete formulation, manufacturing process or exact percentage composition of a product.
The ability to identify or quantify specific components depends on the sample, analytical methods, reference information and agreed analytical scope.
Results should therefore be interpreted within the agreed analytical scope.
Want to Compare Two Products?
Tell us what products you want to compare and what difference you are trying to understand.
You don’t need to choose the analytical techniques yourself.
Labsure can review your requirements and recommend an appropriate comparative analytical program.
From $995 AUD + GST
Typical Turnaround: 20–30 Business Days
